Climate characters: A traitor to one tribe, welcomed into another.
Northwestern University

Climate characters: A traitor to one tribe, welcomed into another.

Meet Bob Inglis. Accepting climate science cost him his seat in the House.

It doesn’t take a PhD. in meteorology to see the climate in a different light.


For former Congressman Bob Inglis, who for 12 years represented the 4th Congressional District of South Carolina (what he calls “the reddest district in the reddest state in the nation”), all it took was the right messenger.

Inglis once called climate change “a figment of Al Gore’s imagination.” But less than a decade later, he betrayed his referent group—or, in his words, his tribe—also known as the Republican Party. He says the change of heart even cost him his seat in the House during the 2010 election. Although he once denied it wholeheartedly, Inglis now believes that climate change is a reality, and that humans are primarily responsible.

Inglis once called climate change 'a figment of Al Gore's imagination.' But less than a decade later, he betrayed his tribe. The change of heart even cost him his seat in the House.

Everything changed when Inglis visited Antarctica in January of 2006 with the House Committee on Science, Space and Technology—a bipartisan delegation traveling to the bottom of the world to watch it begin to disappear.

The group trudged through the snow for a chance to see hard evidence of global warming: cylindrical ice cores 6 inches in diameter and several feet long, which trap years of atmospheric data.

The striped pattern inside, like the rings of an ancient tree, reveal a rise in total greenhouse gases just as the Industrial Revolution kicked off.

Inglis soon joined with another group from the Senate, led by John McCain. When they reached McMurdo Station, a lonely, sprawling research complex nestled at the foot of an inactive volcano on Ross Island’s southern tip, Inglis met a marine biologist whose words would cut deep.

Donal Manahan, a researcher from the University of Southern California, addressed the congressional group in a small classroom. The message was simple: the climate is warming, and humans are responsible.

Manahan planned to spend 20 minutes taking questions, but the session lasted over an hour to accommodate the curious guests. Inglis marveled at Manahan’s ability to cogently answer questions at a GED-level and simultaneously speak eloquently to post-doctoral researchers.

Inglis spoke privately with Manahan at the end of the session, and the conversation turned to the biologist’s ailing mother living in his home country, Ireland. Manahan told Inglis he called her almost every day to check on her condition. With two aging parents himself, Inglis instantly felt a connection. He now cites this intimate conversation as a pivotal moment in his change of heart regarding climate change.

Inglis notes that he could have easily dismissed Manahan as a “Godless liberal” had they not connected personally.

“It takes messengers that mean something to you, and sometimes it’s finding out that they’re not what you thought,” Inglis says. “If people could see Donal Manahan and hear him talk about his mom, they’d realize he has our best interests in mind. We can trust him.”

After the trip, Inglis heard Manahan’s pleas on behalf of the planet echoed by two other trusted sources: by Scott Heron, a climate scientist who shares his conservative politics, and by his own son.

The support Inglis received from friends and family made him feel safe; when he shifted his stance on climate change, he may have betrayed one tribe, but he knew he’d be embraced by another.

“In church, we ask people to come down in front and accept Christ as their savior. It may feel awkward at first, but you’re surrounded by a loving community that’s willing to accept you,” he said.

When Inglis’ beliefs shifted, the support of his own “loving community” gave him the courage to accept the truth about climate change. But it wasn’t enough to save him from his political tribe—the Republicans—who viewed him as a traitor when he began advocating for a carbon tax. In 2010, he lost his seat in the Republican primary.

“The problem in politics is that the people in the pews aren’t disposed to accept you. Once you start down the aisle, they’ll stab you in the back, and step over your dead body,” Inglis said.

When Inglis accepted the 2015 Profile in Courage Award from the JFK Leadership Foundation for his work on climate change, he said it was worth sacrificing the temporary approval of his colleagues for the lasting support of those he loved.

He found the backing he needed in his referent groups—his family, his friends, his church—and he stepped outside the cycle of self-justification to align his beliefs with fact.

SUBSCRIBE TO EHN'S MUST-READ DAILY NEWSLETTER: ABOVE THE FOLD
Support good science journalism
From our Newsroom
environmental justice

LISTEN: Black histories and visions of urban planning

We need to center "lived experience and desire in a way that our existing frameworks don't allow for."

ski wax PFAS

Workers exposed to PFAS in a variety of industries

From construction to skiing, PFAS are an important, but understudied, source of on-the-job chemical exposure.

1872 mining law

Peter Dykstra: The steal of the last century and a half

The General Mining Law of 1872 turned 150 this month. It hasn’t changed a bit.

environmental justice

Op-Ed: Black gold and the color line

How historical racist redlining practices are linked to higher exposures to oil and gas wells.

PFAS Testing

Investigation: PFAS on our shelves and in our bodies

Testing finds concerning chemicals in everything from sports bras to ketchup, including in brands labeled PFAS-free.

Words of wisdom from three leaders in the environmental health and justice field

Words of wisdom from three leaders in the environmental health and justice field

A Q&A with Black and Latina researchers about health equity research and career advice for early career scientists.

Stay informed: sign up for Above the Fold
The most consequential news on your health and the planet: delivered to your inbox every morning. (Weekly roundup also available)