The American Society for Microbiology (ASM) is facing fierce criticism after quietly removing web pages highlighting Black, female, and LGBTQ+ scientists, citing compliance with Trump-era executive orders targeting diversity initiatives.
Usha Lee McFarling reports for STAT.
In short:
- The ASM deleted diversity-focused content, claiming a review is needed to comply with federal executive orders, despite receiving minimal federal funding compared to its other revenue sources.
- Scientists, especially from underrepresented groups, view the move as a betrayal, accusing ASM of performative allyship and caving to political pressure without legal obligation.
- The backlash has spurred calls for boycotts, with members urging ASM to defend diversity in science rather than preemptively comply with controversial mandates.
Key quote:
“To see one of the largest scientific societies in the nation, and one that publishes the leading journals in the field do this, it’s stunning to me. Why are they capitulating in advance?”
— Mark Peifer, professor of biology at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill
Why this matters:
It's more than a skirmish over website content. This represents a flashpoint in the broader battle over who gets to be seen, heard and valued in the scientific community — something that also has implications for research quality. It also raises questions about scientific integrity and independence. Right now, ASM’s actions are telling a story that many of its members aren’t willing to accept.
Read more: Unconventional pathways to science
