China's smoke-belching coal plants and heavy traffic may be signs of a bustling economy but health experts fear the country's dirty air is hurting its babies.
Evidence is mounting that coal and car emissions in China, as well as other developing countries, are raising the risks of premature babies, low birth weights and neural tube defects.
Danger in the womb
"Their cities are in big trouble and so are their babies," said Richard Finnell, a professor at the University of Texas, Austin, who has studied birth defects in North China.
Spurred by sweeping economic gains, a thick layer of soot often hangs over China's cities. Its fine particle pollution is "the worst in the world," said Angel Hsu, a project manager at Yale University's Environmental Performance Measurement program. People in China are exposed to the world's highest levels of fine particles known as PM2.5, according to Yale's rankings. India is close behind.
Scientists say that the dangers begin in the womb.
In a study published in February, fine particles were linked to more low-weight babies in 22 developing countries, including China, India, Nigeria, Nepal and Peru. In China, preterm births also were linked to the pollutant, said the lead author, Nancy Fleischer, a University of South Carolina professor.
Low birth weights were twice as likely and preterm births were 2.5 times more likely among babies born in areas of China where particle pollution was highest, compared with areas where the pollutant complied with World Health Organization standards, according to the study. About 7 percent of China's babies are born preterm, while 6 percent are classified as low birth weight, or less than 5.5 pounds.
Air pollution may contribute to preterm births, low birth weights and birth defects. (Credit: Eden Chalumeau/flickr)
Preterm babies, born before 37 weeks of gestation, are the leading cause of newborn deaths worldwide. These infants are often troubled with a lifetime of developmental and physical disabilities, said Tracey Woodruff, a professor at the University of California, San Francisco, who studies the effects of environmental contaminants on babies.
Skyrocketing birth defect rates
Experts say air pollutants can trigger an immune response in mothers, which produces antibodies that reduce the amount of folic acid that travels through their placentas to their fetuses. Lack of folic acid can lead to birth defects.
"We've looked at placentas from babies that had bad outcomes and compared them to babies with good outcomes and the placentas from babies with bad outcomes have far more antibodies," Finnell said.
Birth defects have increased about 70 percent in China over the past two decades, now reaching about 900,000 per year, according to the country's Ministry of Health. There likely are many factors involved. But regional differences suggest pollutants may be contributing: Birth defect rates more than doubled in urban areas compared with 22 percent in rural areas.
China's Shanxi Province "mines a lot of coal, smelts a lot of steel and has the highest rate of neural tube defects on the planet," Finnell said.
Neural tube defects, which are serious brain and spinal cord disorders such as spina bifida, spiked to about 13 per 1,000 births in the province a decade ago. That is 13 times higher than the rate in the United States.
Outdoor and indoor air pollution poses risks to China's babies. (Credit: Carol Shaffer/flickr)
Mothers' obesity and diabetes are known triggers for neural tube defects, Finnell said, but "coal pollution might play a role, too."
The same year of the spike – 2003 – Shanxi produced 300 million tons of coal and had the highest polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) emissions in China, largely due to coal burning. PAHs are formed by the incomplete combustion of fossil fuels.
Indoors isn't safe
In a study of 130 women in rural Shanxi, those with elevated PAH levels in their placenta were more than four times as likely to have babies with neural tube defects, according to a 2011 study led by Peking University researchers that Finnell was involved in. A smaller study reported that the risk was eight-fold higher than the rate in the United States.
Staying indoors won't necessarily protect the unborn: Indoor air pollution is often even worse. An estimated 3 million people in developing countries cook indoors and heat their home with charcoal, kerosene, biomass, coal or other dirty fuels. Women and children are most exposed.
When pregnant women are exposed to a suite of chemicals, it's hard to figure out which one may be causing their babies' problems, said Amy Padula, a postdoctoral research fellow at Stanford University who has studied birth defects and air pollution.
Cookstoves are a major indoor pollution source in developing countries. (Credit: National Cancer Institute)
"We do know one of the more critical periods for birth defects is early on in pregnancies, during rapid fetal development," Padula said. "It's hard to tease out which one is to blame when we know to a certain extent they're all bad."
In Shanghai, preterm births have been linked to several pollutants: larger particulates known as PM10, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxide and ozone.
Because PM2.5 is a mix of many different contaminants, Woodruff said it is unclear which ones might be linked to lower birth weights. "Researchers have looked at different components, we've looked at different geographies, and no one's found the smoking gun," she said. "We just don't know."
Woodruff said PM2.5's ingredients could adhere to the placenta and alter the development of the placenta bed, which would prevent the fetus from getting sufficient oxygen and nutrients. Pollutants also can alter hormones and disrupt the blood flow across the placenta, Fleischer said.
