Rethinking nostalgia for a healthier America

America’s health history is riddled with tobacco, poor diets and rampant disease, casting doubt on the notion of a bygone era of good health.

Gina Kolata reports for The New York Times.


In short:

  • Historians challenge the idea of a healthier past, noting widespread malnutrition, heavy smoking and untreated diseases from the 19th century through the mid-20th century.
  • Heart disease and cancer were rampant by the 1950s and 1960s, fueled by smoking and limited medical advancements, with death rates far exceeding today’s figures.
  • Modern medicine, including statins and targeted cancer therapies, has dramatically improved outcomes, but health disparities persist and the U.S. spends more per capita on healthcare than any other nation.

Key quote:

“The idea that once upon a time all Americans were healthy is a fantasy.”

— Nancy Tomes, historian, Stony Brook University

Why this matters:

The phrase "Make America Healthy Again" might sound catchy, but let’s be real — it’s rooted more in nostalgia than fact. So, were Americans ever truly healthy? Probably not, at least by today’s standards. But reflecting on this history indicates how far we’ve come — and how far we still have to go. Endocrine disrupting chemicals represent one important, though lesser-known, area of research.

Read more in this 2022 story by Peter Dykstra: WTF RFK Jr.?

About the author(s):

EHN Curators
EHN Curators
Articles curated and summarized by the Environmental Health News' curation team. Some AI-based tools helped produce this text, with human oversight, fact checking and editing.

You Might Also Like

Recent

Top environmental health news from around the world.

Environmental Health News

Your support of EHN, a newsroom powered by Environmental Health Sciences, drives science into public discussions. When you support our work, you support impactful journalism. It all improves the health of our communities. Thank you!

donate